I saw Peter and the Starcatcher (Broadway) on 07/11/12. Overall, I'd say it was a 4-star rating. I'd summarize it by saying “a very inventive production”

Since winning 5 Tony Awards, this show made it to my "must see" list. This is basically a pre-quell to Peter Pan. It is based on a children's book and much of the humor is a little juvenile however there is also a lot of innuendo aimed at the adult audience. The acting was fantastic. Unfortunately Christian Borle was out of the show and probably back in LA shooting the next season of Smash! His replacement did an excellent job.