I saw The Addams Family (Broadway) on 05/16/10. Overall, I'd say it was a 3-star rating. I'd summarize it by saying “Much better than the reviewers said”

I thought the show was clever and funny. Not the train wreck that the reviewers made it out to be. I was thoroughly entertained. Nathan Lane, who I usually don't like, holds the show together and made me laugh. I think it's a fun family show and I understand why it's selling out.